What Size Am I In Aeropostale Jeans

Okay, let’s be real for a second. Standing in an Aeropostale dressing room, holding a pair of jeans that looks like it was sewn for a very tiny, very fashionable elf, is a rite of passage. You pull them on, and suddenly you’re questioning your entire life, your breakfast choices, and whether gravity has personally betrayed you. But here’s the thing: it’s not you, it’s their sizing. And honestly, it’s a little bit like a crazy game of fashion roulette.
The Great Aero Size Conspiracy
First, let’s address the elephant in the fitting room: Aeropostale sizes are wildly inconsistent. You could grab a size 5 in one style and fit perfectly, then try a size 7 in another style and be able to fit a small family in the waistband. It’s not magic; it’s just the chaotic energy of denim. They use “vanity sizing,” which is a fancy way of saying their numbers are inflated to make you feel awesome.
Forget what your “normal” size is at American Eagle or Hollister. That knowledge is useless here. You need to go in with a clear mind and a flexible ego. Think of it like a video game where the difficulty level changes with every pair you pick up. Your mission, should you choose to accept it, is to find the one pair that fits—without crying.
Must Read
Your Secret Weapon: The Stretch Factor
Before you even look at the number on the tag, check the fabric content. Aeropostale has a ton of jeans now with serious stretch, like “Dreamer” or “Jeggings.” These are your best friends. They’re basically leggings that pretend to be jeans, and they forgive all sins, including that extra slice of pizza you had last night. If the label says high stretch, you can usually size down one size because they’ll loosen up as you wear them.
On the flip side, their 100% cotton “rigid” jeans are the villains of the story. These bad boys are unforgiving and will not budge. If you try a rigid pair, go up a size or two, because the fabric has zero give. It’s like trying to get into denim armor. Seriously, I once saw a girl do a full squat in a pair, and the seams just stared back at her, unimpressed.

The Waistband Wisdom
Here’s a pro tip that will save you time: ignore the number on the tag and focus on the waistband. Aeropostale jeans typically sit at a mid-rise, which is great for hiding food babies. But the actual fit around your waist is the true test. You want it snug but not so tight that you can’t breathe. If you have to lie down to button them, they’re too small. That’s not fashion; that’s a medical emergency.
Also, pay attention to the “low rise” styles if you’re feeling brave. Those things sit on your hips like a dare. If you have any curves at all, you might need to size up to avoid the dreaded “plumber’s crack” situation. And remember, we don’t want that. We’re here to look cute, not to give a free show.
The Lengthy Debate (Pun Intended)
Now, let’s talk about length. Aeropostale offers “Short,” “Regular,” and “Long.” If you’re 5’2” like me, you might think “Short” is your jam. But surprise! Sometimes “Short” is still too long, and you’ll be rolling them up like you’re ready for a flood. My advice? Try the “Short” first, but don’t be afraid to grab a “Regular” and just cuff them. Cuffed jeans are stylish and say, “I’m cool and I don’t care about hem lines.”

For my tall queens out there, you’re in luck. The “Long” sizes are actually long, not just “a little less short.” You won’t have to deal with the awkward high-water look unless you want to. But honestly, the length matters less than the butt. Because the ultimate goal is finding a pair that makes your butt look like it was sculpted by angels, right?
The Final Test: The “Sit and Squat”
Okay, you’ve found a pair that zips without a struggle. Congratulations! But don’t pop the champagne yet. The real test is the squat test. Do a deep squat in the mirror. If the jeans cut off circulation to your legs, it’s a no. If they give you a weird camel toe situation, it’s a hard no. And if they slide down your butt when you walk, that’s also a no. You want a pair that stays put but still lets you move.

Remember, a size is just a number. I’ve bought a size 3 and a size 9 in the same trip, and I wore both happily. The only thing that matters is how you feel. Do you feel confident? Do you feel like you can take on the world and also maybe a large fries? If yes, then that’s your size, regardless of what the tag says.
So, What Size Are You?
The frustrating, liberating answer is: you are whatever size fits. And that changes from day to day, hour to hour, and based on whether you’re bloated from soda. So, walk into that store with zero expectations. Grab a pile of jeans in three different sizes and just have a fashion show in the mirror. Laugh at the crazy ones, high-five yourself for the good ones.
And if you walk out with a pair that says a size you’ve never worn before, who cares? You’re not defined by a number on a tag; you’re defined by your killer smile and your ability to find a good deal. So go ahead, rock those jeans. You’re the perfect size, always. Even if that size is “fits me, and that’s all that matters.” Now, go forth and denim, you beautiful legend. ✨
